| Date | Location | Result | |
| Apr 28, 2012 | Elmira, NY | Nazareth College 21, Elmira College 10 | Box score |
| Apr 25, 2012 | Elmira, NY | Ithaca College 15, Elmira College 6 | Box score |
| Apr 21, 2012 | Utica, NY | Utica College 20, Elmira College 16 | Box score |
| Apr 18, 2012 | Hoboken, N.J. | Stevens 20, Elmira College 5 | Box score |
| Apr 14, 2012 | Elmira, NY | Alfred University 18, Elmira College 9 | Box score |
| Apr 07, 2012 | Hartwick | Hartwick 18, Elmira College 13 | Box score |
| Apr 04, 2012 | Elmira, NY | St. John Fisher 18, Elmira College 8 | Box score |
| Mar 31, 2012 | Williamsport, Pa. | Lycoming 15, Elmira College 9 | Box score |
| Mar 24, 2012 | Elmira, NY | College at Brockport 14, Elmira College 11 | Box score |
| Mar 16, 2012 | Elmira College | Rensselaer 11, Elmira College 5 | Box score |
| Mar 14, 2012 | Elmira, NY | Elmira College 17, Keuka College 11 | Box score |
| Mar 11, 2012 | Winchester, Va. | Elmira College 12, Shenandoah Hornets 8 | Box score |
| Mar 03, 2012 | Elmira College | Elmira College 19, La Roche College 8 | Box score |